Wednesday, 15 July 2015

Eating slugs – and a fascinating defence mechanism



Mention slugs to people and you are likely to get "Ugh!" as a response - and from gardeners a more hostile reaction. This is because slugs are slimy and they also eat plants, often in competition with humans when we are growing plants for food or decoration.


To a Natural Historian, slugs are fascinating, as they are gastropod molluscs that have lost their shell during evolution. Adult gastropods, with few exceptions, move using muscular contractions and expansions of the foot, sliding over a film of secreted slimy mucus. Production of mucus is also important in providing a body covering to prevent desiccation and as a deterrent to predators. Nevertheless, many slugs are predated and gardeners are encouraged to provide areas for hedgehogs or predatory birds. One solution to the pest problem that is rarely mentioned is the collection of slugs for food, just as we gather some types of snails (Roman snails, winkles, whelks, etc.). Here is a recipe adapted from one posted on the "eattheweeds" website [1]:

Allow slugs to feed on salad leaves and then kill them in a vinegar-water mixture before boiling them in water, repeating this three times. The prepared slugs can now be used to make patties.

Beat 3 eggs with 3 tablespoons of double cream and add the mixture to 3 tablespoons of flour, the same quantity of cornmeal, and 10 slugs (chopped into bite-sized pieces). Whisk, form into patties, and then fry in butter. Serve with bread and salad.

Some of you may find this low on your list of recipes to try, but slugs are attracting the interest of at least one celebrity chef [2] and they are a source of protein that is readily available. Hugh Fearnley-Whittingstall recommends slugs cooked in a tomato sauce [2].

Less familiar to us than terrestrial slugs are those that live in the sea and these are not easily gathered in quantity, so are unlikely to be utilised widely as food. There are reports of sea slugs being eaten by humans, but these accounts arise from confusion with sea cucumbers (holothurian echinoderms) that are eaten in many parts of the World. Holothurians formed part of the famous dinner of the Acclimatization Society in 1862 where views on flavour and consistency were mixed [3]. However, true sea slugs are now finding their way on to speciality restaurant menus [4] – and note that the article refers to them as "trash from the sea". It is an unfortunate term for remarkable and beautiful animals.


It was a sea slug, Marionia sp, that I "adopted" at the UCL Grant Museum of Zoology [5]. It is mounted with the foot facing the viewer and this was done to allow students, and other observers, to see the dimensions of the foot and thus the area in contact with the substratum (see above left).  Unfortunately, preservation in spirit removes pigment and the living specimen would have been light orange in colour, providing camouflage (see above right). Reference to the Sea Slug Forum [6] shows the range of sea slugs and some of their extraordinary adaptations and beautiful colours. These colours are not for our appreciation, of course, although a Creationist might disagree, but to provide warning or camouflage. Warning of what? I'll come to that question, but first we need to know a bit more about the body plan of sea slugs and how they are different to snails.


During evolution, some of the internal organs of gastropods underwent torsion, with the gut opening forward into the mantle cavity at the shell entrance. Slugs, including sea slugs, have undergone de-torsion, with the anus being towards the rear, nearer to their ancestral positions. The anterior end of the gut of snails and slugs features a rasping tongue, or radula, and this is used to remove food from the surface of stones or vegetation, or for scraping away the tissue of living plants and animals. Marionia feeds on corals [7] and the Grant Museum specimen, labelled Marionaria quadrilatera (but actually Marionaria blainvillea) would have fed on these colonial animals while living in the Mediterranean Sea.

A characteristic of corals is the ability of individual polyps to retract and to use stinging cells as a means of catching food, just like their relatives the jellyfish (many corals also generate their own food by harbouring algal cells within their tissues). The stinging cells, or nematocysts (see below), have a trigger that releases a thread through which toxins are injected to immobilise prey, a series of small barbs holding the thread into the tissue. They also serve in defence and a grazing sea slug will be at risk of being attacked by these stinging threads as they eat the coral tissue, even when polyps are retracted. The evolution of stinging cells in coelenterates is an amazing adaptation, but there are some sea slugs that eat coral tissue without the nematocysts discharging. Not only that, intact cells can be moved to extensions of the body, called cerata, on the back of the sea slug through branches of the gut that extend into the projections. Any animals attacking these sea slugs now receive stings from coral nematocysts and the bright colour of the molluscs probably acts as a warning.


Slugs may not appeal to everyone, but we should all be amazed at some of their adaptations. How these evolved can only be speculated upon, but there are few examples in nature as extraordinary as the evolution of nematocysts by coelenterates, followed by their hijacking by some sea slugs. It's worth thinking about if you feel tempted to eat some.




[3] G.H.O.Burgess (1967) The Eccentric Ark: The Curious World Of Frank Buckland. New York, The Horizon Press.






The UCL Grant Museum of Zoology gave permission for me  to use the photograph of the preserved Marionaria specimen.






Thursday, 2 July 2015

Two wonderful Museums – and mention of another



As a child, I was fascinated by a box that was kept in a back room of our house and which contained "curios". I cannot remember all the bits and pieces in the box, but there was a claw (from a tiger?) and some coarse hair that was said to come from a giraffe's tail. It was our family's cabinet of curiosities, like those kept by Nineteenth Century collectors and Natural History enthusiasts, but I've no idea where the claw and hair came from. Perhaps they were given to my parents by a contact who, unlike us, had travelled widely? I now think the source was more likely to be Paignton Zoo, within easy walking distance of where we lived.

It is possible that my interest in Natural History Museums developed from my fascination with the curios, although I also enjoyed looking at plants and animals while walking in the countryside, or looking in rock pools and streams. It certainly grew when I went into the Sixth Form of Torquay Grammar School and began studying Botany and Zoology at A-level. For some reason, our classes in those subjects were held at the local Technical College, that shared the same campus as the school, and this brought much more freedom. Instead of going to the School Library, a group of us now spent time collecting animals on the shore during our free time, something that was completely against school regulations. Occasionally, we made trips to Exeter to visit the Royal Albert Memorial Museum and little did I know then that the RAMM was to provide a delightful surprise over fifty years later when a Curator, Holly Morgenroth, kindly let me see their collection of drawings by Henry and Edmund Gosse [1,2] – and to think they were there during my schoolboy visits all those years before (although not on display).

It was during the Sixth Form that I joined the Torquay Natural History Society and this allowed me free access to talks and also to their Museum. It was rather musty and dark at that time, not like the welcoming place it is today, and I spent hours in the Library, with its smell of dust and old leather, and volumes going back to the Seventeenth Century. One I remember was printed in London in 1666 and that set me thinking whether this was before, or after, the Great Fire and what a story that book could tell. Being free to look through the exhibits and the books was just like being given a very large box of curios to me. 


The Torquay Museum is housed in a building dating from 1874 (see above), collections previously having been in more temporary quarters [3]. The secretary of the Torquay Natural History Society from 1851 to 1890 was William Pengelly who was made an FRS for his many contributions to palaeontology, especially after the excavation of caves in the Torbay area.  A quote from a biography of Pengelly by his daughter [4] emphasises the central role he played in the development of the Society and I certainly owe him a debt of gratitude, for my love of museums started in Torquay:

It was indeed mainly due to Mr Pengelly's energy that the autumn of 1844 witnessed the foundation of the Torquay Natural History Society. Over its early fortunes he exercised the most watchful care, and in 1851 he was induced to accept the office of honorary secretary, an office which he continued uninterruptedly to hold, to the unspeakable advantage of the Society, for no less than nine-and-thirty years.. ..Year after year he lectured there, tincturing the locality with his own enthusiasm; and from the Society there ultimately sprang the Museum in Babbacombe Road, with its admirable local collections. In the reading-room attached to the Museum there fitly hangs an oil-painting of the man whose individuality is unmistakably marked upon the entire institution – William Pengelly

Pengelly, unlike the "other Torquay  FRS", Henry Gosse, was a regular visitor to London and he was acquainted with E. Ray Lankester, the eminent Zoologist who held the Jodrell Chair at University College London, attending conversazione that were held by that great academic. Lankester had a wide circle of friends and contacts, extending to Karl Marx, H. G. Wells and Anna Pavlova, so he wasn't just well known in his own field. In their monograph on Lankester [5], Lester and Bowler state that, although they mainly communicated through correspondence, he "much admired" Gosse and Edmund Gosse writes [6]:

Among the younger zoologists of the day, few of whom were personally known to my father, there was not one in whose discoveries and career he took a livelier interest than in those of Professor E. Ray Lankester, for whom, from his earliest publications, he had predicted a course of high distinction.


As Jodrell Professor, Lankester inherited the Zoology Museum built up by his predecessor Robert E. Grant (for whom the museum is now named), adding considerably to the collection. The museum is still used for teaching undergraduate and postgraduate students, but it is also open to the public and all who visit appreciate its wonders as it has a powerful atmosphere of the glory days of the Nineteenth Century [7]. Its current location, that shows off the collections so well, is the latest in a series and one hopes that it will remain there for a long time. Of course, the Grant Museum of Zoology is not just about teaching and connecting with the heyday of Natural History; it is also very contemporary, with some wonderful displays to attract and fascinate visitors [8] and a blog that is always worth reading [9]. One novel approach to develop interest is a scheme to adopt a specimen and I did this eagerly, choosing a sea slug Marionia quadrilatera (see below, with the adoption certificate). I chose it as I taught Aquatic and Invertebrate Biology, and a sea slug is appropriate for both. Interestingly, it was part of the collection added to by Lankester and may well have been one of the many specimens brought back from Naples in 1885 [5] by Alfred Gibbs Bourne, a student of Lankester's (note that the jar is labelled "Naples").



While a member of staff at UCL, I listened to one neophyte colleague chatting about the destiny of the Museum of Zoology and how much better it would be to use space for laboratories and contemporary biomedical research. I found this sad and was delighted to serve on the UCL Museums and Heritage Committee where there were never discussions of this kind and where we focussed on the marvellous collections held by the University. Heritage is so important and I'm delighted that Lankester still looks out at the Museum (albeit from a photograph – see below - with specimens of Limulus, about which Lankester wrote an important essay [5]), just as Pengelly looked out in the Library of the Museum in Torquay. I like those connections.






[4] Hester Pengelly (1897) A Memoir of William Pengelly, of Torquay, F.R.S., Geologist. London, John Murray.

[5] Joe Lester and Peter J. Bowler (1995). E. Ray Lankester and the Making of Modern British Biology. British Society for the History of Science Monograph 9.

[6] Edmund Gosse (1896) The Naturalist of the Sea-Shore: The Life of Philip Henry Gosse. London, William Heinemann.





Photographs were taken with the permission of the UCL Grant Museum of Zoology.

Friday, 26 June 2015

Decoration in humans and other animals



A wide variety of animals decorate their outer surface. In a review paper, Graeme D. Ruxton and Martin Stevens [1] have defined a decorator as:

..an organism that (by means of specialist behaviour and/or morphology that has been favoured by selection for that purpose) accumulates and retains environmental material that becomes attached to the exterior of the decorator.

This definition is a bit complicated as it is designed for an audience of scientists, but you get the drift. Ruxton and Stevens then give us some examples, beginning with decorator crabs (below left) that attach all sorts of materials to hooked hairs present over the body of the animal:

Several studies..have found that experimentally altering or removing decoration [from decorator crabs] increased vulnerability to predators.. ..Items used in decoration are often chemically defended plants or sessile animals, and it seems plausible that predators detect the crab but actively avoid attacking because of the repellent smell or taste from the decorations. However, not all decorations provide the animals with chemical defence, and it is likely that decoration often functions through crypsis via background matching, masquerade and/or disruption.


Another type of decoration is seen in insects that use faecal shields, an example being larvae of the tortoise beetle (above right), where faecal pellets are retained on an extension of the body, so that the solidified shield provides cover for attack by predators. The shield acts both in crypsis and as a physical defence [1], isolating the body from potential attacks; other insects use a covering of faecal material directly on the surface of the upper body. However, decoration in insects is not confined to the use of faeces: other components of "backpacks" may be cast skins from moults, or organic, and mineral, grains obtained from the surrounding environment and stuck on to the back by secretions, or held there on hairs extending from the body surface.

Decoration is also used by birds (and I am not including those, like bower birds, that make collections of bright objects remote from the animal itself). To quote Ruxton and Stevens [1]:

In birds, a range of species add substances to their feathers that alter their appearance (termed cosmetic coloration).. Staining of the feathers with soil has been observed in a number of large birds.. ..Both sexes [of the rock ptarmigan] sport all-white plumage at the start of the breeding season, as snow melts this becomes very conspicuous and females moult to produce feathers that appear to offer good camouflage. By contrast, males do not moult immediately, but smear their feathers with soil before later moulting into a brown plumage.

Free-ranging adult bearded vultures..typically have an orange colour on their underparts, neck and head conferred by iron oxide-rich soils.. .. Colour tends to be greater in (socially dominant) females than males and increases progressively from juveniles, to immatures, to sub-adults to adults.

Ruxton and Stevens conclude their review by saying [1]:

Decorating is a particularly diverse activity, and (like tool-use) it is difficult to produce an unambiguous definition that covers all cases effectively.. .. Anti-predator benefits are most commonly postulated, in contrast to humans where decoration functions strongly in social interactions.

Their last sentence set me thinking. Unless one believes in Creation, it is not possible for us to look at the behaviour of our own species without realising that much of it developed as we evolved so successfully away from the rest of the Animal Kingdom. In this post, I describe the origins of human decoration, confining myself to clothes, accessories and make-up, as these best fit the definition given above.

Humans lack a dense covering of hair over the whole body and it is likely that our first use of decoration was by draping ourselves in animal furs that were protective and helped to keep us warm. It could be argued that this enabled early humans to migrate to regions with cooler climates, something that was also facilitated by the discovery of fire, but it is unlikely that animal pelts provided camouflage against predators. Camouflage coverings are certainly important in providing crypsis in warfare and they form an important part of the clothing using by contemporary fighters (below), together with applied face paints. This is analogous to the main use of decoration used by animals but most of our clothing, in addition to its functions of keeping us warm and protected, is used in expressing social status, for mate selection, or for group identity.


Among contemporary costume, the business suit is currently de rigeur for men in many countries and in many walks of life, with only small changes in the design of a jacket and trousers. There is status in having a designer label and this is true also of all clothes, something that conveys both the quality of materials and tailoring, but also exorbitant cost. The expression of wealth in this way is important in Western Society, as is the quantity of items in an individual's collection. Surprisingly, while the business suit represents a work uniform (although casual clothes for men are more varied), women's fashion is based on variety, and it is considered acutely embarrassing to wear an outfit that is identical, or too similar, to that worn by someone else at the same social function. Despite trends in fashion, decoration in women is thus less about uniformity and more about the uniqueness of the individual. Why?

The answer to this question probably lies ancestrally in mate selection. Humans do not have a breeding season and mating can occur at any time through the year. Mate selection is based on genetic factors – the classic notion of handsome men and beautiful women pairing up – but also on decoration. Clothes are an important part of this and initial mate selection is often influenced by clothes, as these convey information about social status and identity, something that is important if mate selection is for the long-term and where breeding is likely. Of course, there are more factors than decoration involved in selection, but it forms an initial signal, with most encounters initiated by men.

In addition to the decoration provided by clothes, there are also accessories, especially used by women, and we all know individuals with a shoe and/or handbag addiction. The most similar parallel to animal decorators comes in jewellery in all its forms. This type of decoration may emphasise status, as in the integration of precious stones, or be used as a symbol of lack of availability, as in wedding rings. Similar forms of decoration are present in many tribal cultures, not just those of the Developed World, and extend to neck rings, necklaces, nose plugs and rings, ear plugs, earrings and many other forms. They are not confined to women either, as they are used by both sexes as indicators of cultures and sub-cultures, something unknown among animals other than humans.


It is ironic that one design of earrings is based on the activity of an animal decorator. Larvae of some caddis flies make cases of stones that are bound together with silk secreted by the insect. This habit has been utilised by jewellers who give larvae semi-precious stones and wait for each earring to be produced [2]. It's the only example I can think of where the activity of one decorator animal is used by another, albeit for a different purpose.

In addition to clothes and accessories, considerable attention is given to enhancing the appearance using paints and powders of various kinds. Use of ochre and ash in face and body colouration is a characteristic of some "primitive" tribal groups, but make-up in Western Culture is usually more subtle, with concentration on the face. As with clothes and accessories, there are variations but, in general, powders are used to enhance the complexion and to hide blemishes, while various products are used to decorate the eyes and lips to provide emphasis. Although men use cosmetics, women are the main users and, as with other forms of decoration, the underlying message is related to mate selection and/or belonging to a social group.  


Just as humans evolved rapidly, so did our use of decoration. It now has many forms and is constantly changing, except in tribal cultures and where national costume, or work customs and uniforms, create an identity. However, we are animals and the origin of our use of clothing, accessories and make-up lies far back in evolutionary time.


[1] Graeme D. Ruxton and Martin Stevens (2015) The evolutionary ecology of decorating behaviour. Biology Letters 11: 20150325.







Wednesday, 17 June 2015

How did humans become such unique animals?



After conducting experiments on the preferences of "semi-free-ranging" chimpanzees when presented with cooked food, Felix Warneken and Alexandra G. Rosati [1] suggested that: "The transition to a diet of cooked foods – involving the use of heat in food preparation – was a fundamental change for our species." This point was taken up in an article by Pallab Ghosh, the BBC Science Correspondent [2]:

According to Dr Warneken [and Dr Rosati], his experiments show that most of the mental skills needed to cook were there in human ancestors between 5 to 7 million years ago and so all it took for the first emergence of the culinary arts was the controlled use of fire and the ability to trust other people not to pinch our food while our back was turned..

..The motivation for the study was to investigate a controversial theory that cooking was necessary for human brains to become larger. The idea by the primatologist Prof Richard Wrangham.. ..is that cooking enabled our ancestors to eat more protein, which helped our ancestors develop their brains.

The BBC article went on to include extracts from an interview with Professor Fred Spoor of UCL:

Cooking did not happen until 300,000 to 400,000 years ago. That is late in 7 million years of human evolution, so to put it bluntly, who cares that early humans may have liked the idea of cooked food?..

..Substantially larger brains initially emerge around 1.5 million years ago and a major leap was around 500,000 years ago.

The series of quotes led me to think about how humans developed their unique position in the Animal Kingdom, with the power to manipulate the environment to an extent quite unlike that of any other organism. I dismiss the Creationist argument that humans resulted from the invention of a supernatural force and accept that our extraordinary capacities evolved from the nucleus of possibility in our ape-like ancestors. It was the phrase "the ability to trust other people not to pinch our food while our back was turned" that had me wondering about an explanation.


Let's assume our distant ancestors lived in family groups and that they foraged for food, gathering vegetable material and hunting animals, all of which were eaten without cooking, as this method of food preparation had yet to be discovered. Families are closely related genetically and the survivorship of individuals, and thus their "selfish genes", will have been enhanced if the hunters were successful in providing plentiful food to ensure the survival of all individuals. Let's assume further that hunters from several families joined together to make hunting more efficient and make the capture of larger prey possible. Interactions between members of this larger group would have required signals – vocalisations, movements of limbs, and facial expressions – that had evolved to give clearly understood information.

After years of successful co-operative hunting, what if one group of individuals gave the signal to co-operate, but then took the catch for themselves, maybe killing some individuals in other families to ensure plenty for their own family at a low cost? The signals no longer have their original meaning and the offer to form joint hunting groups, of advantage to all participants, now carries the risk of a different, less advantageous, outcome. There was thus a need to interpret meaning in communication, with the most successful manipulators, and the best readers of false signals, having the highest chance of survival.

If there was also selection of the optimal neural pathways needed to aid interpretation, these would be fixed in the population and the process of analysing hunting signals, and signals of many other kinds, would become more and more refined. This new consciousness would extend to humans asking questions about the environment around them, forming a complex language structure to explain meaning, and, with further development of the brain, a need to ask abstract questions like: "Why are we here?”; “Is there a supernatural force?”; and “What is good and evil?”.

Or perhaps it was not like that at all?


[1] Felix Warneken and Alexandra G. Rosati (2015) Cognitive capacities for cooking in chimpanzees. Proceedings of The Royal Society B 282: 20150229. http://dx.doi.org/10.1098/rspb.2015.0229