Wednesday, 7 October 2015

Noah's Ark – a likely story?



It is a steep climb up to the Alhambra in Granada, so, on a recent visit, I was pleased for the break provided by an exhibition of giant photographs alongside the path. The images were of mountains from around the World and each had a caption in both Spanish and English. 




One of the photographs was of Mount Ararat and the English translation of the caption, together with the picture, is shown above. It said:

Mount Ararat 5137 m, 39° 42' 10" N, 44° 18' 01" E (Turkey). The highest point in Turkey is a huge stratovolcano very near the border of Armenia, where it is highly symbolic. Its place among sacred mountains comes from the Book of Genesis, which says that it was here that Noah's Ark landed after the Great Flood. Even though that has not been proven scientifically, the link between this peak and the Holy Scriptures is now unbreakable.

What interested me most about the caption to the photograph was the last sentence. How can the presence of Noah's Ark on Mount Ararat be proven scientifically? What would one look for: pieces of ancient wood remaining in clefts in the rock that could be carbon-dated? Of course, it is most improbable that any evidence of the presence of the Ark will ever be found and Wolfgang Kaehler, who wrote the caption, must be aware of that. He must also be aware that the "unbreakable" link between Ararat and the Ark is a result of the repetition of a single statement in The Bible. This is the quote from Genesis Chapter 8 Verse 4 (Authorised Version of the King James' Bible): "And the ark rested in the seventh month, on the seventeenth day of the month, upon the mountains of Ararat."
 


What would a scientist make of the rest of the story of Noah's Ark and the Great Flood, as given in the Book of Genesis (some verses omitted)? [1]:

I will destroy man whom I have created from the face of the earth; both man, and beast, and the creeping thing, and the fowls of the air; for it repententh me that I have made them. But Noah found grace in the eyes of the Lord.. ..And God said unto Noah, The end of all flesh is come before me; for the earth is filled with violence through them; and, behold, I will destroy them with the earth. Make thee an ark of gopher wood; rooms shalt thou make in the ark, and shalt pitch it within and without with pitch. And this is the fashion which thou shalt make it of: The length of the ark shall be three hundred cubits, the breadth of it fifty cubits, and the height of it thirty cubits.. ..And, behold, I, even I, do bring a flood of waters upon the earth, to destroy all flesh, wherein is the breath of life, from under heaven; and every thing that is in the earth shall die. But with thee I will establish my covenant; and thou shalt come into the ark, thou, and thy sons, and thy wife, and thy sons' wives with thee. And of every living thing of all flesh, two of every sort shalt thou bring into the ark, to keep them alive with thee; they shall be male and female.

From this, we know therefore that the ark was 114-156 metres long, 19 – 26 metres wide, and 11 – 16 metres high. Its construction would have been a formidable challenge, even for a team of boat builders, and many people must have been curious as to why Noah had decided to create such a huge craft. It could hardly have been a secret shared only between Noah and his immediate family. As to the likely passengers, there would not be enough room for two of all species of terrestrial creatures (if this was to be based on species) and what about those creatures that do not have male and female forms? As God had created microorganisms, protists, simple plants and invertebrates, it is not known whether these were to be saved, and "every living thing of all flesh" is difficult to interpret.

Just before the flood [2]:

..Noah went in, and his sons, and his wife and his sons' wives with him, into the ark, because of the waters of the flood.. ..In the six hundredth year of Noah's life, in the second month, the seventeenth day of the month, the same day were all the fountains of the great deep broken up, and the windows of heaven were opened. And the rain was upon the earth forty days and forty nights.. ..and the waters increased, and bare up the ark, and it was lift up above the earth. And the waters prevailed, and were increased greatly upon the earth; and the ark went upon the face of the waters. And the waters prevailed exceedingly upon the earth; and all the high hills, that were under the whole heaven, were covered.. ..And all flesh died that moved upon the earth, both of fowl and of cattle, and of beast, and of every creeping thing that creepeth upon the earth, and every man: all in whose nostrils was the breath of life, of all that was in the dry land, died. And every living substance was destroyed which was upon the face of the ground.. ..And the waters prevailed upon the earth an hundred and fifty days.

Here, we have clarification that "every living substance" remaining on Earth failed to survive the flood, with the inundation lasting nearly five months. There is still no information about which of the "living substances" were taken on board the ark, but the removal of all humans, other that Noah and his offspring, means that we must all have descended from this lineage. Noah's great age seems typical for the time, his ancestors dying when they were 777 – 969 years old, having fathered children at the ages of 65 – 187 [3]. Clearly, there was a different life span in those days, or the Biblical account of age cannot be trusted. Evidence points to the latter, with an increasing life expectancy over the past thousand years that is unlikely to have been bettered in ancient times. Very few people now live to be more than 110 years old and to father children at an age of 150+ is unheard of. Clearly, Biblical references to time must be viewed with suspicion.

Another question that arises from the account in Genesis is what happened to aquatic organisms. The volume of fresh water that appeared from the rains (but where did these come from in such massive volumes) would allow survival of many creatures that lived in rivers and lakes, but those inhabiting marine shores would have been badly affected by the reduction in salinity. As waves and storm events only affect the very surface waters of oceans, and the fresh water of the Great Flood would "float" on the salty sea water, it is likely that most marine organisms, other than those confined to surface waters, survived the flood, although no mention is made of this. For those who believe in evolution, life began in the sea, so there was the opportunity of re-colonising terrestrial habitats once the flood had abated, although the time to achieve the current diversity is impossibly short – it would take hundreds of millions of years – and the only explanation acceptable to those who take the Bible to be true, is that re-colonisation was by the survivors from the ark.


The story of Noah's Ark seems highly improbable, but that does not rule out the possibility that there was a large-scale flood at the time. In an earlier article [4], I proposed that the chronology of the Ten Plagues of Egypt could be explained by unusual climatic conditions and there have undoubtedly been periods of the Earth's history when there were dramatically volatile meteorological events, especially after asteroid impacts, volcanic eruptions, earthquakes, and other massive upheavals. Perhaps the flooding at the time of Noah resulted from one of these?

[1] Genesis Chapter 6 Verses 7,8,13-19 Authorised Version of the King James' Bible (https://www.biblegateway.com/)

[2] Genesis Chapter 7 Verses 7,11,12,17-19,21-24 Authorised Version of the King James' Bible (https://www.biblegateway.com/)

[3] Genesis Chapter 5 Authorised Version of the King James' Bible (https://www.biblegateway.com/)

Thursday, 24 September 2015

The evolution of a fascinating mutualism



How did mutualisms between individuals of different species develop? These associations take many forms, but some symbioses evolve so that dependence results; the best known examples being lichens, where fungi and algae live together to mutual advantage.

A symbiosis is found between a species of hermit crab, Pagurus prideaux and a sea anemone Adamsia palliata (pictured below, the Adamsia having pink spots), although it is not essential for the survival of each [1]. There are many species of hermit crabs, but all are characterised by having a soft abdomen that is held within a snail shell left behind after the gastropod has died. This is a remarkable association between a living animal and the remains of another and, as an individual crab grows, it leaves one shell and searches for another that is more suitable for its increasing size. The aperture of shells occupied by P. prideaux usually has an individual of A. palliata attached to it, located the entrance in a position where it doesn't have a marked effect on the centre of gravity of the shell.


The advantages of symbiosis between sea anemones and hermit crabs have been reviewed by Gusmão and Daly [2], with the sea anemones benefitting from an increase both in dispersal and in the chance of encountering food; and the hermit crabs being protected against predators by the stinging cells of the sea anemone. So how does the sedentary sea anemone move to the snail shell occupied by the crab? The locating behaviour was described by Philip Henry Gosse, the great nineteenth-century Natural Historian. Here is his observation [3]:

Carefully taking up the shell with the aquarium-tongs, and bringing it close to the surface, but not out of water, I gently dislodged the Adamsia with my fingers, and allowed it to fall prone upon the bottom. I then released the shell with its tenant, and drove the latter towards the spot where the zoophyte lay.

No sooner did the Crab touch the Adamsia than he [sic] took hold of it with his claws, first with one, then with both, and I saw in an instant what he was going to do. In the most orderly and expert manner he proceeded to apply the Adamsia to the shell. He found it lying base upward, and therefore the first thing was to turn it quite round. With the alternate grasps of the two pincer-claws, nipping up the flesh of the Adamsia rudely enough, as it seemed, he got hold of it so that he could press the base against the proper part of the shell, the inner lip. Then he remained quite still, holding it firmly pressed, for about ten minutes; at the end of which time he cautiously drew away first one claw, and then the other; and, beginning to walk away, I had the pleasure to see that the Adamsia was once more fairly adhering..

Long-term attachment is aided by the secretion of chitin, this being a feature of several sea anemones and not just Adamsia. However, the chitin produced by Adamsia forms an extension of the snail shell and, in the following description of the process [4], the reference to chitine and a horny membrane come from the observations of Henry Gosse:

..sea anemones of the genus Adamsia living on gastropod shells inhabited by hermit crabs may extend the shell's lip by secreting what is variously called a cuticle, "chitine", a horny membrane, or solidified mucus.

This is what Gosse wrote in Actinologia Britannica [5]

Very frequently, there is found intervening between the Adamsia and the shell to which it is affixed, a film of membrane, of a horny texture, somewhat brittle, of a translucent dark greenish-brown colour. After death this film is found adherent to the surface of the shell, from which, however, it easily peels when dry.. ..From several specimens.. .. I have been able to learn the nature and object of this membrane.. ..it appears to me manifest that the membrane is a provision for the support of the growing Adamsia.. .. it is composed mainly of chitine, having no calcareous element.. .. The membrane is not invariably present.

Gosse goes on to say [5]:

Pagurus Prideauxii seems to be as dependent on the Adamsia, as the latter is on it.. ..Why one species of Soldier-crab must needs seek the companionship of this Anemone, while other Soldier-crabs are able to live alone; and why this species of Anemone must needs associate with the Soldier-crab, while others kinds of Anemone are solitary, I can by no means answer.

As described above, we now have information of the mutualism and how it benefits both partners. For Henry Gosse (whose beautiful illustration is shown below), the association of the hermit crab and gastropod shells and the mutualism between Pagurus prideaux and Adamsia palliata were yet more wonderful examples of the complexity of God's Creation.


For those of us that believe in evolution, it is fascinating to speculate on the various steps that must have taken place to allow the association between the crab and the shell, and then the crab and the sea anemone. The secretion of chitin by the sea anemone was a pre-adaptation and may have originally been a means of ensuring that broken, or friable, substrata could be colonised. It now results in the secure attachment to snail shells and gives the hermit crab the advantage of changing shells less frequently. How did the crab learn to transplant a sea anemone on to a new shell; and why this one species?

Evolution fills one with a sense of wonder, doesn't it?


[1] R. M. L. Ates (1995) Pagurus prideaux and Adamsia palliata are not obligate symbionts. Crustaceana 68: 522-524.

[2] Luciano C. Gusmão and Marymegan Daly (2010) Evolution of sea anemones (Cnidaria: Actinaria: Hormathiidae) symbiotic with hermit crabs. Molecular Phylogenetics and Evolution 56: 868-877.

[3] Philip Henry Gosse (1865) A year at the shore. London, Alexander Strahan.

[4] Daphne Fautin Dunn and Martin H. Liberman (1983) Chitin in sea anemone shells. Science 221: 157-159.

[5] Philip Henry Gosse (1860) Actinologia Britannica: a history of the British sea-anemones and madrepores. London, Van Voorst.

Wednesday, 16 September 2015

Sea silk – the Natural History of an unusual textile




Anyone preparing mussels for moules marinières [1] is familiar with the beards that need to be pulled free of the closed shell. These beards are more properly termed byssus threads and they are the means by which mussels attach to substrata, allowing them to withstand the effects of waves and water currents. Unlike snails, bivalves do not use their foot for gliding locomotion and, instead, it provides an effective burrowing organ or, in mussels and their relatives, a means of secreting threads and then holding them in tension. The threads are produced from a gland on the foot and pass along a groove, being attached to the substratum and the foot then withdrawn, each proteinaceous thread hardening very rapidly and thus ensuring secure attachment. The bivalve shells are opened by the elastic hinge when the muscles that hold the valves tightly together are relaxed and the mussels then feed on the good supply of suspended food particles brought by tidal flows.

 
Pinna nobilis, commonly called the pen shell, is a large bivalve that can grow to 1 metre in length and it requires strong attachment by byssus to avoid being moved by currents and to hold the animal upright to allow efficient feeding (an example of a pen shell is shown in the video clip above). Pen shells are found on soft bottoms but are most commonly associated with beds of seagrasses, underwater flowering plants that are anchored into sediments by means of rhizomes [2]. In a study in the Ebro Delta in Spain, Prado et al [3] concluded that:

Seagrass beds have been considered to be the most suitable substrate for P. nobilis, since their rhizomes allow a complex connection between byssus filaments and the sediments. In fact, although individuals were detected in both vegetated and unvegetated areas, higher abundances (by ca. 40%) were observed in areas with 80%-100% cover, thus suggesting that dense meadows may favour the highest abundances of individuals.

In addition to providing ideal locations for attachment, seagrass beds are also highly productive marine habitats and it is likely that these provide an abundance of food for the growing bivalves. The large number of shells also provides good conditions for the colonisation by plants and animals; shells from dead bivalves transplanted experimentally into areas of bare soft sediment readily became colonised by a diverse community of marine creatures [4].  


The natural community of Pinna nobilis, and its associated plants and animals, could not develop if it were not for byssus, recognised increasingly as an important biomaterial [5]. Byssus consists mainly of collagen, a fibrous protein that shares many characteristics with fibroin, the main constituent of insect silk. The most well known insect silk is that produced by silkworms to form a cocoon in which to pupate. The pupae and cocoons are harvested and it is important that these are placed into boiling water to kill the pupae before the adult insects emerge to cut through the threads. The long fibres are unwound and, as they are produced by being exuded through an aperture, they are uniform in both diameter and consistency. Byssus threads, on the other hand, vary in diameter and they are usually elliptical in cross section, a result of their method of production from the byssal gland and byssal groove on the bivalve foot.


It may come as a surprise to know that the byssus of Pinna nobilis is collected, carded and spun to produce a thread used in weaving, knitting and embroidery. Recently, this use was highlighted in an article on the BBC web site [6] that included a portrait of Chiara Vigo, a Sardinian collector, weaver and embroiderer and the strong feeling and respect that she has for byssus. The same attitude is shown by Felicitas Maeder who has a wonderful web site that is packed with historical and scientific information, as well as having an illustrated inventory of many items made from sea silk. If you are interested in the Natural History of this unusual material, an historian of textiles, or an enthusiast for weaving, knitting and embroidery please visit http://www.muschelseide.ch/en/projekt.html. It is a fascinating site and makes one wonder about the evolution of byssus and the ingenuity of humans who saw it as a useful fibre, both for clothing and ornament.




 



[3] Patricia Prado, Nuno Caiola and Carles Ibáñez (2014) Habitat use by a large population of Pinna nobilis in shallow waters. Scientia Marina 78:555-565

[4] Lotfi Rabaoui, Walid Belgacem, Dorsaf Ben Ismail, Lamjed Mansour and Sabiha Tlig-Zouari (2015) Engineering effects of Pinna nobilis shells on benthic communities. Oceanologia 57:271-279.

[5] J. Herbert Waite and Christopher C. Broomell (2012) Changing environments and structure-property relationships in marine biomaterials. The Journal of Experimental Biology 215:873-883.