Showing posts with label Crows. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Crows. Show all posts

Monday, 2 May 2016

Angels, Nike, Superman and Darth Vader




Before the invention of powered flying machines, humans could only move through the air using balloons carried by winds. Now we can travel more or less anywhere at speed, and we are no longer confined to Earth, so the mystique of flying is much less that it was hundreds of years ago. Nevertheless, we are fascinated by birds because they evolved powered flight using their own bodies and there has always been a rich mythology attached to birds and the places that they can reach. Using our imagination, we borrowed one of their major attributes – wings – and used these in our depiction of flying creatures like angels that are portrayed as humans with bird wings that enable them to fly between Earth and Heaven. This image has persisted for centuries and probably originated in statues of Greek goddesses, such as Nike, that have a clothed human form, with wings in addition to arms (when they are not broken off... see above).

In paintings, most angels are shown having predominantly white wings, an example being Guercino's St Sebastian succoured by angels (below, upper), although there are exceptions to this convention, as seen in works by Fra Angelico (below, second) and Veronese (below, third). Bright colour was a common feature of places of Christian worship in the first half of the last millennium, so it is not surprising that religious paintings are similarly brightly coloured. White wings, however, have another symbolic role. They remind us of doves, released as symbols of peace and reconciliation, and long portrayed in paintings as representing the Holy Spirit, as in the Double Trinity of Murillo (below, bottom).


If white is good, then black is evil in western Culture and birds like crows have a quite different reputation to that enjoyed by doves. They are known from ancient folklore as bringers of bad luck and even death [1], and they are potent symbols of evil in paintings, such as those by Giovanni Bellini (below, upper) and Mantegna (below, middle). Even though these illustrations are details from larger works, the prominence, and isolation, of the birds conveys a powerful message. Crows add to the forbidding tone of Van Gogh's Wheatfield with Crows (below, bottom), painted shortly before he died from infection following a self-inflicted gunshot wound. Although the overall colours of the painting convey gloom, imagine how the work would look without the crows and then think whether the atmosphere would be more, or less, menacing.


From mythology then, we conclude that white, or brightly coloured, wings are features of good angels, while evil angels, or angels of death, have black wings. In contemporary culture, we extend this metaphor by using capes; items of clothing designed originally to provide freedom of movement. Note that Superman (below) has a red cape that is fastened at the shoulders, just like angel wings. We know that Superman can fly, and that he came from another world, and we also know that flight was achieved through superhuman powers, just like those of angels. The cape is a symbol of Superman's ability to fly, just as bird wings are for angels, and it separates him from the merely human.


Although they do not appear in the same fantasy, Darth Vader of Star Wars (below) represents the antithesis to Superman. We see him as an imposing figure in black with a black cape held at the shoulders, just like that of Superman. The colour reminds us of evil and the visual imagery works before we ever know of Darth Vader's intentions (by the way, the "baddies" often wore black hats in early Western movies).


It is fun to think of Superman as a good angel (with some messianic qualities) and Darth Vader as an evil angel, but how odd they would look if earlier conventions had been followed and they were given bird wings of an appropriate colour instead of capes. Can you imagine it?

[1] Steve Roud (2003) The Penguin Guide to the Superstitions of Britain and Ireland. London, Penguin Books.

Sunday, 8 February 2015

Crows and impending doom



We project emotions on to crows. Being black, their feathers have the Western colour of mourning and they have become associated with impending doom.

Two paintings sum up this projection. In the first of these, Van Gogh’s Wheatfield with Crows of 1890 [1] the colouring is sombre and crows are flying towards us. Although I am not a fan of most of van Gogh’s work, this painting had a powerful impact on me when I first saw it and it is the crows, painted with crude strokes, that carry most of the threat of something bad about to happen. There are more than 40 of them (were they rooks, the close relatives of crows and known to be more social?) and they fly obliquely towards the observer from a distant point in the dark and threatening sky.


The second painting, Boy with a Crow, was completed in 1884 [2], six years earlier than the work by Van Gogh, when the artist, Akseli Gallen-Kallela was just nineteen years old. This painting is less well known than Wheatfield with Crows but it matches it, or even surpasses it, for the threat of bad times, especially as the victim of potential misfortune is also included. A young boy looks over a small patch of ground to something in the distance, but out of the picture. Meanwhile, a solitarily hooded crow is pecking at the ground and looking at the boy with its left eye. That patch of land, probably part of a larger plot, may be essential for grazing by animals and thus survival of a young family, for the climate in Finland is harsh for half of the year and the barefooted boy’s clothes show that his parents are poor.


It is not only the black colour of crows that provides a sense of threat, but knowing that they, and their close relatives, feed on carrion, although this is only part of the diet [3, 4]. We have an aversion to carrion, and to animals that feed on dead bodies, while recognising that carrion feeding is an essential part of the normal functioning of ecosystems. Our feelings about feeding on already dead bodies is not confined to crows: compare our admiration for eagles capturing, and killing, their prey with our view of squabbling vultures at the remains of a lion kill and, while mentioning lions, compare our reaction to seeing these big cats bring down a zebra, or wildebeest, with our attitude towards hyenas finishing off the carcase and eating the bones. Eagles and lions are considered noble and powerful (they are even combined in mythical gryphons), whereas vultures and hyenas are somehow skulking and despicable.

Crows are intelligent and successful birds and, like vultures and hyenas, do not deserve their reputation. However, that reputation sticks. Imagine our reaction to Van Gogh’s painting if it was parrots flying towards us, or, in Gallen-Kallela’s masterpiece, if it was a duck that was looking askance at the boy?




[3] J.D.Lockie (1956) The Food and Feeding Behaviour of the Jackdaw, Rook and Carrion Crow. Journal of Animal Ecology 25: 421-428.

[4] Roger Tory Peterson, Guy Mountfort and P.A.D.Hollom (1993) Collins Field Guide to the Birds of Britain and Europe. London, HarperCollins.